Airplane Crash

Bodensee Germany
2002, July 1, 11.43pm local time


a) Boeing 757

began flying in 1982 and final assembly of the series -- the 757-200, 757-300 and the 757 Freighter -- is done at the Boeing plant in Renton, Washington.

In July 2000 Boeing began converting 44 757-200 jetliners to freighter configuration for DHL Worldwide Express. Part of the conversion involved cutting into the fuselage and fitting a 20-by-22-foot cargo door, replacement of selected floor panels, strengthening of the main deck floor, and installation of a cargo handling system.

The converted 757 freighters are capable of carrying 60,000 pounds of cargo and have a range of more than 2,000 nautical miles.

Accidents involving 757:

  • 1990 October 2nd. China, Guangzhou Airport: a China Southwest Airlines Boeing 757 was hit on the ground by a hijacked Xiamen Airlines Boeing 737; 46 of the 144 people aboard the 757 died

  • 1995 December 20th. Colombia, Cali: an American Airlines Boeing 757 crashed during landing approach, 160 people died, 4 survived

  • 1996 February 6th. Dominican Republic: Birgenair Boeing 757 en route to Germany, crashed in the sea minutes after take off Puerta Plata airport, all 189 people died

  • 1996 October 2nd. Peru, Lima:: AeroPeru Boeing 757 crashed into the sea after taking-off from Lima International airport, all 70 people aboard died

  • 1999 September 14th. Spain, Gerona Airport: Britannia Airways Boeing 757 crashlanded in heavy rain, departed the runway after a nose gear failure, slid into a field, and broke into three pieces; all 245 people aboard survived

  • 2001 September 11th. US, Pennsyvania: One of the four aircraft hijacked by terrorists -- United Airlines Flight 93, which crashed in a field in Pennsylvania -- was a Boeing 757.


b) Questions

How did the two planes get so close to each other in the first place, as they approached at right-angles on exactly the same altitude?

Why was only the Russian pilot apparently told to take avoiding action?

Why was the first instruction given to him only 50 seconds before impact - and what caused him to apparently miss or ignore it?

Tragically, within seconds of the Russian pilot heeding a second instruction to dive, a collision avoidance computer on the DHL plane suddenly told its pilot to do the same.

In other words, verbal instructions from air traffic controllers to the Russian crew, and computer instructions on the 757, put the planes on a deadly new collision course.

Attention in the inquiry may also focus on the handover of the flights to Swiss air traffic controllers. The Russian plane was handed over from German traffic controllers only five minutes before the crash, while the DHL plane had been handed over by Italian controllers just a few minutes before that.

The planes were already on a collision course - albeit about five minutes away - when the Germans completed the handover.

If the handover does turn out to be a factor in the crash, it will strengthen the argument for Europe's proposed Single Skies system, which would replace individual countries' airspace with an entire European Union zone.

And the fact that pilots have to change radio frequencies as they move across European air space could also come under the spotlight. Investigators will want to be sure that the Russian plane was listening to the right air traffic control frequency when controllers first tried to make contact.

Another area for investigation will be language. The instructions to the Tu-154 was given in English by a Swiss controller to a Russian crew - though so far there has been no suggestion that a misunderstanding occurred.

Why were the instructions given to the Tupolev passenger jet not coordinated with the DHL aircraft?

Whatever the final conclusions, it is likely that a sequence of events - rather than a single catastrophic mistake - was to blame for the tragedy.




If you have any questions or comments, or if you would like to share
your experiences with us, we would be more than happy to hear from you.
CONTACT US